Talk:Amarak/Archive 1

Discussion page of Amarak/Archive 1
Revision as of 02:26, 4 December 2005 by Lestatdelc (talk | contribs) (I have doubts about the veracity of the claim of Amorak not being abord the Olympic)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

I have doubts about the veracity of this claim:

"At no time is it clear whether or not Amorak was aboard the Olympic Carrier, or whether the use of his name in these events was merely a Cylon ploy to further manipulate Baltar, drawing him further into their influence."

We do know that Dr. Amorak (or a humano-cylon) was initially onboard the Olympic before it failed to make jump 238. We know this because Billy informs President Roslin of the request received from the Olympic before the jump that someone onboard the Olympic calling themselves Dr. Amorak had urgent information for the President and had to be delivered in person. This was not simply in Baltar's head. It could be argued that the entire Olympic had be compromised at the time the request came across to Colonial One but this seems suspect as there would presumably have been direct contact with the people onboard the Olympic prior to the events we witness in 33. This would indicated that either Dr. Amorak was really aboard the Olympic before jump 238 failed, and was simply part of the passengers taken over after it failed to jump, or that Dr. Amorak was a humao-cylon before getting onboard the Olympic.

Or am I missing somethiing here? — Lestatdelc 21:26, 3 December 2005 (EST)